[sakai2-tcc] add Target version field in Jira?

Neal Caidin nealcaidin at sakaifoundation.org
Tue Mar 12 19:09:26 PDT 2013


Hi TCC, 

This has come up before, recently I think, but I bring it up again because I think there is still a need. As I work on a query to cross projects for identify issues for qa testing, merging, etc, I still see an important use case of Jiras which it is not clear if they are intended for a particular release (2.9.2, for example), and after the fact, to identify issues that have been merged into the release (inconsistent use of fix version). 

Two possible strategies, both of which seem reasonable to me are:

1) Use of labels. The advantage of labels is that across the main project and indie projects we can use the same label to tie things together for a particular release, even with indies on different versions. One label, 292triage for example, can tie together disparate versioning conventions across MSGCNTR, LSNBLDR, BASICLTI, SAMIGO, etc. This should make it easier to do clean up on the fix version and help with queries for merging and testing (it did for me and the QA group in 2.9.1). 

OR 

2) Add a Target version field in Jira, in addition to the affects version and fix version.  The advantage of a target version is that it will make it clearer which version an issue is intended to be included in (though extra translation may be needed to the overall release version) and it will also clear up confusion around the fix version, which many still use as a target version field. 

If you don't like either of these ideas do you have alternatives that might address these issues? If you are not convinced there is a need, I wonder how I can convince you? Hypnotism? Psychedilics? <just kidding!> You are feeling very sleepy. Oh, wait, that's me after a large dinner. Nevermind.

Wondering if I should loop in QA and Dev groups. Folks in QA group definitely are with me on this issue, I would say. 

Cheers,
Neal



More information about the sakai2-tcc mailing list